The Best Grilled Cheese in San Diego, By Category

Grilled cheese has quietly become one of San Diego's more competitive food categories — dedicated shops, gourmet twists, diner classics, and a well-known national chain that built its whole identity around the sandwich. Here's the honest pick in four categories.

Best Reviewed Grilled Cheese: The Melt

Grilled cheese isn't a side note for The Melt — it's the origin of the name and the concept the whole menu is built around, and the review data backs that up. Its Grilled Cheese Sandwich shows up as one of the most-reviewed individual menu items across Melt locations, with the Three Cheese Classic and its variations consistently pulling strong ratings wherever the chain operates. Combined with the sheer review volume at its San Diego locations (900-plus at the Gaslamp location alone, with a 4.7-out-of-5 aggregate), it's a rare case of a grilled cheese with a large enough sample size to actually trust the rating rather than going on a handful of enthusiastic reviews.

Runner-up mention: Mad Munch Grilled Cheezer, a San Diego favorite on multiple local "best of" lists, has built a smaller but consistently glowing review base of its own.

Best Overall Grilled Cheese: Sunny Side Kitchen

Sunny Side Kitchen, a mom-and-pop shop in Downtown Escondido, has the strongest verified claim to "best overall" in this category: its grilled cheese was voted Best Grilled Cheese in the county by readers of the San Diego Union-Tribune in 2022. The sandwich itself justifies the accolade — two creamy white cheeses (Havarti and Muenster) between slices of artisan sourdough from local bakery Bread & Cie, finished with shredded Parmesan on the outside of the bread for an extra layer of crunch and flavor. It's a simple concept executed with real technique, which is exactly what separates a great grilled cheese from an average one.

Runner-up mention: Board & Brew, a San Diego sandwich institution with multiple locations, is a reliable classic if Sunny Side Kitchen isn't convenient to your neighborhood.

Best Gourmet Grilled Cheese: Grater Grilled Cheese

Grater Grilled Cheese built its entire concept — starting as a food truck more than six years ago — around treating grilled cheese as a genuine culinary category rather than a kids' menu afterthought. The chef-inspired, loaded versions push well past bread-and-cheese basics, and the shop's reputation across its San Diego and Chula Vista locations has made it a consistent name on "best of" lists for the category. If you want a grilled cheese built with real intention rather than as a side note to a burger menu, this is the specialist to go to.

Runner-up mention: The Melt's Three Cheese Classic — cheddar, muenster, and fontina on crispy artisan bread — is a solid "elevated but accessible" option if you want a gourmet-leaning sandwich without a dedicated specialty-shop wait.

Cheapest Grilled Cheese: Rudford's

For a genuinely affordable grilled cheese, Rudford's — San Diego's classic 24-hour diner in North Park — is hard to beat. It's the kind of no-frills, old-school diner menu where a grilled cheese is still treated as a basic, inexpensive comfort-food order rather than a $12-plus specialty item, and the round-the-clock hours mean you can get it whenever the craving hits without paying a premium for it.

Runner-up mention: Most classic diners and delis around the city keep a basic grilled cheese on the menu at a similarly low price point — worth asking about off-menu if you don't see it listed.

The Final Cheese Pull

San Diego's grilled cheese scene has more depth than the sandwich usually gets credit for — Sunny Side Kitchen for a verified, award-winning classic, Grater for a dedicated gourmet specialist, Rudford's for a genuinely cheap version, and The Melt for the sandwich it built its name on, backed by real review volume. The Melt earns its spot here because grilled cheese is quite literally its founding product.

New privacy policy
(upated May 2006)